My Stepdaughter Gave Me Adult Diapers and a Nursing Home Brochure for Christmas in Front of the Whole Family. Then I Handed Her the Gift I’d Been Hiding for Two Years
The first time I met Lauren, she told me I was sitting in her mother’s chair. It was a Sunday dinner at Frank’s house, about five years ago. Frank had made a pot roast and was so nervous he’d forgotten to turn on the burner under the green beans. I’d sat down at the end of the table nearest the kitchen, because that was the chair he pulled out for me.
“That’s Mom’s,” Lauren said from the doorway. She was twenty-seven then, tall like her father, with her car keys still in her hand. “She sat there for thirty years. So she could get up for things.”
“Lauren,” Frank said.
“I’m just telling her, Dad. She wouldn’t know.”
I moved to the chair by the window. I said I was sorry and that of course I hadn’t known. Lauren sat down across from me and didn’t speak to me again until the pie, when she asked how old I was. I told her I was sixty-three. She looked at her father, who was fifty-nine, and raised her eyebrows, and went back to her plate.
I didn’t hold it against her. Her mother, Diane, had died two years before that dinner, of ovarian cancer, after fourteen months of treatment that hadn’t worked. Lauren had moved back home for the last four of those months and slept on a cot in the den. I knew something about that kind of year. My husband, Ray, died of a stroke in our driveway while he was carrying in the groceries, and for a long time afterward I couldn’t stand to see anybody else use his coffee mug.
My name is Carol. I was a dental hygienist for thirty-eight years in the same office in Grandville, Michigan, which is how I knew Frank in the first place. I cleaned his teeth twice a year for two decades. I knew about his crown on number nineteen long before I knew his middle name. After Diane died, he missed three appointments in a row. When he finally came in, he sat in my chair and cried with the bib on, and I shut the door and let him.
We were married a year after that pot roast, at the courthouse, with his sister Peggy and her husband as witnesses. Lauren came. She wore black slacks, stood at the back, and left before lunch.
Before the wedding, I did something Frank thought was unnecessary. I went to an attorney named Susan Abernathy, who’d handled Ray’s estate, and had her draw up a prenuptial agreement. It said that Frank’s house, the one he and Diane bought in 1989, would go to Lauren when he died, and that I gave up any claim to it. I’d have the right to live there for a year afterward and that was all. Frank said I was being morbid. I told him I’d watched what second marriages did to some of the families who came through our office, and I wanted it in writing that I wasn’t after his daughter’s house.
He signed it and put his copy in the fireproof box in the basement. He never mentioned it to Lauren. That’s how Frank handles most things.
For the first couple of years, I tried everything I could think of. I invited Lauren for dinner on Sundays, and she came about one time in four. I asked about her job. She’s a veterinary technician at a clinic in Kentwood, and she’s good at it, and she’d answer me in single sentences while looking at her phone. I learned not to move anything in that house. The first spring, I took Diane’s photograph off the piano to dust underneath it and set it back an inch to the left, and Lauren noticed within ten minutes of walking in.
She called me Carol when she called me anything. To other people, I heard later, she called me “Dad’s roommate.”
Frank would tell me to give it time. Peggy, who has never been shy, told me I should quit bending over backward for a grown woman who was acting like a twelve-year-old. I thought the truth was somewhere in between. Lauren wasn’t cruel by nature. I’d watched her carry a neighbor’s old cat into the house wrapped in her own coat. She was a person who’d lost her mother at twenty-five and had decided that being nice to me would be a way of agreeing to it.
Then, two and a half years ago, her grandmother died, and things got worse.
Ruth was Diane’s mother. She was ninety-one and had been in a memory care unit for three years, and Lauren drove out to see her every other Saturday, though Ruth no longer knew her name. Ruth owned one thing of any value, a small cottage on Loon Lake, up north, about two hours from us.
I’d never seen it then, but I’d heard about it constantly. Ruth’s husband built it in 1958 with lumber from a torn-down schoolhouse. Diane spent every summer of her childhood there, and so did Lauren. There was a framed picture in Frank’s hallway of Lauren at about six, standing on a dock in a red swimsuit, holding up a bluegill no bigger than her hand, with Diane laughing behind her. Frank told me Diane had asked to go up there one last time, the September before she died. He’d carried her down to the dock in a lawn chair.
Everyone had assumed the cottage would come to Lauren eventually. Diane had assumed it. But after Diane died, Ruth’s son, Gary, flew in from Arizona and took his mother to see a lawyer. Ruth signed a new will that left everything to her one surviving child. I don’t know how much Ruth understood by then. Nobody ever challenged it, and I’m not saying anyone should have. It was done properly, with witnesses, and that was that.
Gary inherited the cottage in June. By August, there was a sign from a realty company nailed to the birch tree at the end of the driveway. He listed it for two hundred and fourteen thousand dollars.
Lauren found out from a Facebook post. A girl she’d grown up with on the lake shared the listing with a crying face.
She called her uncle that night. I only know that conversation from what Frank told me, but apparently Gary said he hadn’t set foot in the place since 1996, he had two kids with student loans, and he wasn’t running a museum. He told her she was welcome to make an offer like anyone else.
Lauren tried. She went to her credit union and sat down with a loan officer. She makes a decent wage for what she does, but she had about thirty thousand in student loans, a car payment, and four thousand dollars in savings. The loan officer was kind and told her no in about fifteen minutes.
So she came to her father. It was a Thursday evening in early September. I was in the laundry room folding towels, and they were in the kitchen, and I heard all of it, though I didn’t mean to.
“I’ll pay you back every cent,” Lauren said. “I’ll put it in writing. I just need the down payment, Dad. Forty thousand. Then I can get the mortgage.”
“Honey, I don’t have forty thousand dollars.”
“You have your 401(k).”
There was a long quiet. Then Frank told her what he had never told her before. Diane’s treatment had been at a clinic in Chicago that their insurance called out of network, and the last drug they tried had cost more a month than he earned. He’d taken out most of his retirement savings to pay for it. He’d put a second mortgage on the house too, and still owed about sixty thousand on that. He was sixty-two years old and working full time at the heating and cooling company because he couldn’t afford not to.
“I’d do it again,” he said. “For your mother, I’d do it twice. But I don’t have it, Lauren. I’m sorry.”
I heard her chair scrape back.
“You had money for a cruise,” she said. Her voice was shaking. “You and Carol went to Alaska for ten days in June. You had money for that.”
“Carol paid for that.”
“Of course she did.” Lauren laughed, and it was an ugly sound. “So she’s got money. That’s nice. Mom’s cottage is getting sold to some dentist from Chicago so he can tear it down and build a garage for his boat, and you’re on a cruise.”
The back door slammed hard enough to rattle the dryer.
I came into the kitchen after I heard her car start. Frank was sitting at the table with his hands flat on the placemat. He’d printed out the real estate listing at work, and it was lying in front of him, six color photographs on a sheet of paper. A brown cottage with white trim. A screened porch. A dock.
“She used to count the steps down to the water,” he said. “Twenty-two. Diane taught her to count on those steps.” He rubbed his eyes with the heel of his hand. “I can’t fix it, Carol. I can’t fix one damn thing for that girl.”
I stood behind his chair and put my hands on his shoulders, and over his head I read the price on the listing a second time.
I had the money. That’s the plain fact of it, and it’s what I lay awake with that night.
When Ray died, there was a life insurance policy through his union. When I married Frank, I sold the house Ray and I had lived in for thirty-one years. Altogether, I had about two hundred and thirty thousand dollars in a money market account at my credit union, in my name. Susan had been after me to do something sensible with it. I’d been leaving it alone, the way you leave a closet you’re not ready to clean out.
Ray and I never had children. We tried for a long time and then we stopped talking about it. I mention it because I think it mattered to what I did next, though I couldn’t have explained how at the time. I had no one to leave that money to except a nephew in Oregon who sends a card at Christmas.
I thought about just giving Lauren the forty thousand. I could picture exactly how that would go. She’d have thrown it back at me, or worse, she’d have taken it and hated me for every dollar. And Frank would never have allowed it. He has more pride than sense about money, and he’d already had to tell his daughter he was broke. He wasn’t going to let his new wife bail him out in front of her.
So the next morning, after Frank left for work, I called the number on the listing. Then I called Susan Abernathy. Then, because it seemed like the decent thing, I found Gary’s phone number in Frank’s address book and called him in Arizona myself.
He remembered who I was, barely. I told him I wanted to buy the cottage for my stepdaughter and that I’d pay cash. I asked him for one favor, which was to keep my name to himself until I’d had the chance to tell her.
“Lady, I don’t talk to that side of the family as it is,” Gary said. “Your check clears, you can tell her the Easter Bunny bought it.”
I offered two hundred and five thousand. He took it the same afternoon.
I didn’t tell Frank. I’ve gone back and forth on whether that was right, and he has his own opinion, which I’ll get to. At the time, I told myself that he’d refuse, and that if he didn’t refuse, he’d never manage to keep it from Lauren for more than a week. Both of those things were true. It’s also true that it was easier for me not to have the argument.
The closing was on the second Tuesday of October, at a title company in the little town nearest the lake. I told Frank I was driving over to Ludington to see my cousin Barb. I felt sick about the lie the whole way up, and I did stop and see Barb on the way home, for twenty minutes, so it wouldn’t be a complete one.
A woman named Jeanette handled the paperwork. Gary had signed his part ahead of time in front of a notary in Scottsdale. I signed my name about fifteen times and handed over a cashier’s check, and Jeanette slid a small manila envelope across the desk.
“Keys,” she said. “The seller’s realtor dropped them off. I guess they were his sister’s.”
There were two keys on the ring, both brass and worn smooth. The ring itself had a fishing bobber on it, the old-fashioned kind, red on top and white on the bottom, with the paint chipped off one side. I held it in my palm in the parking lot for a while before I started the car.
The cottage was eleven miles out of town, down a gravel road and then a two-track through the pines. The realty sign was still on the birch tree. I pulled it up myself and laid it in the weeds.
I don’t know what I’d expected. It was small and dark brown, with a mossy roof and a screened porch that sagged at one corner. The door stuck. Inside, it smelled like woodsmoke and mothballs and lake water, and it was so full of Diane’s family that I stood on the mat and didn’t go any farther for a minute.
Nobody had cleaned it out. Gary hadn’t bothered, and the realtor had only
pushed things back against the walls for the photographs. There was a jigsaw puzzle of a covered bridge on the card table, two-thirds done, under a film of dust. A row of faded life jackets hung on nails by the door, in sizes from toddler to adult. On the inside of the pantry door, somebody had marked heights in pencil going back to the sixties. Diane’s name was there, climbing up the wood year by year, and beside it, in different handwriting, Lauren’s.
In the kitchen drawer, I found a spiral notebook with a pen tied to it on a string. It was a logbook. Every visit for forty years had an entry, the date and the weather and who came and what they caught. The last one was in a shaky hand I recognized from the Christmas cards Frank kept in his desk. It was dated in September, six years earlier, and the whole entry was one line. Frank carried me down. Water like glass. D.
I sat down on a kitchen chair and cried for a woman I’d never met, in a house I’d just bought with my dead husband’s insurance money, and I felt like a trespasser.
I didn’t touch anything. I walked down the steps to the dock, and I counted them, and there were twenty-two. Then I locked up and went next door, where there was smoke coming out of the chimney.
The neighbor was a retired tool and die maker named Arnie Kowalski, who’d lived on the lake year-round since his wife passed. He knew the whole family. He came out on his porch in suspenders and looked me over with real suspicion until I told him why I’d bought the place. Then he took off his cap and scratched his head.
“Diane’s girl,” he said. “Well, I’ll be. I figured it’d be a teardown.”
He agreed to drain the pipes before the freeze and keep an eye on the place. I offered to pay him, and he said forty dollars a month would cover his gas and his trouble. I asked him not to say anything if Lauren ever came by. He said he could keep his mouth shut, he’d been married forty-four years.
Susan Abernathy thought I’d lost my mind, and she told me so in her office the following week. She’s a small, blunt woman with a gray bob who has been practicing law in Grandville since before I got my first pair of bifocals.
“You’ve bought a two-hundred-thousand-dollar house for a young woman who won’t pass you the salt,” she said. “I want it on the record that I asked whether you were sure.”
“It’s on the record.”
“Fine.” She put on her glasses. “How do you want to do this?”
She prepared a quitclaim deed, one page, transferring the cottage from me to Lauren. I signed it in front of her and her notary. She explained that it wouldn’t mean anything at the courthouse until it was recorded with the county up north, and that I could hold on to it and hand it over whenever I liked. She also had me add a line to my own will, so that if I got hit by a bus in the meantime, the cottage would go to Lauren anyway. I thought that was sensible.
I bought a flat white shirt box and a roll of silver wrapping paper. I folded the deed and put it in the box with the two brass keys on their bobber ring, and I wrapped it and wrote Lauren’s name on a tag. I put it on the top shelf of the hall closet, behind the vacuum cleaner bags, where Frank hasn’t looked in thirty years.
My plan was to give it to her that Christmas, ten weeks away. I had it all pictured. She’d open it by the tree, and she’d understand that I wasn’t trying to take anything from her, and we’d finally be able to start.
That Christmas Eve, Lauren came for dinner with her boyfriend at the time, a quiet fellow named Derek who sold insurance. We got as far as the salad. Then she noticed that I’d hung two of my own ornaments on the tree, a pair of glass cardinals Ray had bought me on our twentieth anniversary. They were on a low branch, nowhere near Diane’s handmade felt ones, which I had put in front where they always went.
“So we’re just adding things now,” Lauren said.
“They’re a couple of birds, honey,” Frank said.
“It’s Mom’s tree.”
“It’s a Fraser fir from the Boy Scout lot,” Frank said, more sharply than I’d ever heard him speak to her. “And Carol lives here.”
Lauren put her napkin down. She said that the cottage had closed in October, in case anyone cared. Some woman had bought it for cash, and she hoped her father had enjoyed Alaska. Then she looked at me and said the thing I haven’t forgotten.
“You can hang whatever you want,” she said. “You’re still not my mother, and you can’t buy your way into being her.”
She and Derek left before the ham was carved. Frank went out to the garage and stayed there an hour.
I went to the hall closet and looked up at the silver box on the shelf. If I’d handed it to her the next morning, she would have seen it as proof of exactly what she’d accused me of. I pushed it farther back behind the vacuum bags and shut the door.
I had not thought very far past that first Christmas, and suddenly I owned a lake cottage in secret.
The county sends property tax bills twice a year up there, one in the summer and one in the winter. I had them mailed to a post office box I rented for eleven dollars a month. Together they came to a little under four thousand dollars a year. There was insurance on top of that, and Arnie’s forty dollars, and a propane bill I hadn’t counted on. I paid all of it out of my own account and kept the receipts in an accordion folder in my sewing basket.
I drove up three or four times a year, always on some excuse. I never stayed overnight. I’d open the windows and sweep up the dead flies and sit on the porch for an hour. I didn’t finish the jigsaw puzzle, and I didn’t write in the logbook, because it wasn’t mine to write in. Arnie would wander over with a thermos and tell me which neighbors were feuding about a boat lift.
In the spring of that first year, Peggy called me. Lauren had been at her house for Easter and had told her, after two glasses of wine, that she’d driven up to Loon Lake by herself one Saturday in March. She’d parked at the end of the two-track and walked in. The place was closed up tight, with the shutters on, and she’d stood in the yard and looked in through the gap in the porch screen. Then she’d sat down on the steps and cried until her feet went numb.
“She said nobody’s even using it,” Peggy told me. “She said that’s the worst part. Somebody bought it and they’re letting it sit there.”
I almost told Peggy then. I had my mouth open to do it. But Peggy tells her husband everything, and Walt tells the entire Elks lodge, and I shut it again.
I did go to Susan and ask her whether I should just mail Lauren the deed.
“You could,” Susan said. “Legally, it makes no difference how she gets it.” She took off her glasses and cleaned them on her sleeve. “But you didn’t spend that kind of money so she’d get an envelope from a law office. You want to be standing there. So wait until you can stand there.”
The second Christmas, Lauren didn’t come at all. She and Derek had broken up in the fall, and she volunteered to work the holiday at the emergency animal hospital so the technicians with children could be home. She dropped off a gift card for her father on the twenty-third while I was at the grocery store. The silver box sat on its shelf for another year.
I’d be lying if I said I didn’t have doubts. There were nights I thought I had done a foolish, vain thing. I had lied to my husband by omission for two years. I’d let a grieving young woman believe her mother’s cottage belonged to strangers when one sentence from me would have ended it. I’d been waiting for a moment when she liked me enough to accept it, and it was looking like that moment might never come.
This past October, Frank turned sixty-five, and he finally let me drag him back to Susan’s office to update his will. It hadn’t been touched since Diane was alive. It was a short meeting. The will said what the prenup already said, that the house would go to Lauren, and he signed it and we went to lunch.
He left the folder from the law office on the kitchen counter. Lauren came by that Saturday to borrow his ladder, saw Susan’s letterhead, and drew her own conclusions without opening it.
I was upstairs, and I came down partway through.
“I’m not stupid, Dad. People don’t go to a lawyer at your age for no reason. You’re putting her on the house.”
“I’m not putting anybody on anything. Sit down and I’ll explain it.”
“She’s four years older than you are. Do you get that? She’s almost seventy. In ten years you’re going to be changing her diapers and paying for some nursing home, and when you’re both gone there won’t be anything left of what you and Mom had. That’s the plan. I’m just planning ahead, since nobody else is.”
Frank told her to take the ladder and go home. She did. He never got to explain the folder, and then his pride set in, and he said he’d be damned if he’d chase after her to show her a will that left her everything. They barely spoke in November.
I didn’t expect her at Christmas. But the week before, she called her father and said she’d come for brunch and presents on Christmas morning, if that was all right. Frank was so relieved that he went out and bought the good bacon. Peggy and Walt were coming, with their grown twins, and Frank’s mother, Josephine, who’s eighty-nine and lives in an apartment at Maple Creek. It would be eleven of us with the twins’ wives.
On Christmas Eve, around nine at night, the phone rang. It was Peggy, and she was whispering, which is not her usual volume.
“Carol, I need to warn you,” she said. “Lauren was over here this afternoon dropping off the kids’ presents. She told me what she bought you. She thinks it’s hilarious.”
“What is it?”
Peggy told me. I sat down on the arm of the couch.
“I told her it was mean,” Peggy said. “She says it’s a gag gift and you need to learn to take a joke. Please don’t open it in front of everybody. Take it in the other room, or say you’ll save it for later. Don’t give her the satisfaction.”
“Thank you for telling me, Peg.”
“What are you going to do?”
“I don’t know yet,” I said, and that was the truth.
After I hung up, I stood in the front hall for a long time. Frank was asleep in his recliner with the television on. I opened the closet and reached up behind the vacuum bags. The silver paper had gone a little dull, and one corner was dented, and the tag still had her name on it in my handwriting from two years before.
I carried it into the living room and slid it under the back of the tree, behind the stand, where no one would notice it.
Christmas morning, the house was full by ten. Walt had brought his sticky buns. Josephine was settled in the wing chair with an afghan over her knees, and the twins were arguing about football. Lauren came in last, in a green sweater, carrying a shopping bag. She kissed her father and her grandmother. She said, “Merry Christmas, Carol,” in a bright voice I hadn’t heard from her before, and Peggy looked at me across the room.
We do presents youngest to oldest in Frank’s family, which meant that I was second to last, just before Josephine. I had an hour to sit there and think. I watched Lauren open a new set of scrubs from Peggy and a framed photograph from her grandmother, and I watched her laugh at something her cousin said. She looked very much like the six-year-old on the dock.
When it got to me, there was a pair of slippers from Josephine and a cookbook from the twins. Then Lauren reached into her shopping bag and brought out a large box wrapped in snowman paper, with a big red bow.
“This one’s from me,” she said. She set it on my lap herself. She had her phone in her other hand.
I could have carried it into the bedroom, as Peggy had said. I thought about it. But I’d spent five years stepping around this girl, moving to the other chair, pushing boxes to the back of closets, and I was sixty-eight years old and tired of it.
I untied the bow and lifted the lid.
It was a package of adult incontinence briefs, the big economy size, with a smiling gray-haired couple on the front. Lying on top was a glossy brochure for a place called Sunset Pines Assisted Living, with a photograph of a fountain and the words Because Every Chapter Deserves Comfort.
The room went silent. One of the twins’ wives said, “Oh,” very quietly.
Lauren was laughing. She laughed so hard she had to wipe her eyes with the cuff of her sweater.
“It’s a joke!” she said. “Come on, you guys. You’re so old, Carol. I’m just planning ahead.”
Frank stood up out of his recliner. His face was a color I’d only seen once before, when a contractor cheated his mother.
“Lauren, that’s enough.”
“It’s a gag gift, Dad.”
“I said that’s enough. You apologize to her right now, or you can take your coat and…”
“It’s fine, Frank,” I said.
It wasn’t fine. My face was burning, and my hands weren’t steady, and I’m not going to pretend I felt serene. I felt old and foolish with that box on my knees. But I put the lid back on and set it on the floor beside my chair, and I managed to smile at her.
“Thank you, Lauren,” I said. “Now I have something for you, too.”
She stopped laughing. “You already gave me the gift card.”
“This is a different one.”
I got down on my knees, which takes me a minute these days, and reached in behind the tree stand. I pulled out the flat box in its dull silver paper and held it out to her.
She took it with a little shrug at her cousins, as if to say she’d play along. She tore the paper off one end and slid the box out. She wasn’t expecting anything. I think she assumed it was a scarf.
She lifted the lid and folded back the tissue paper.
The keys were lying on top of the deed. Two worn brass keys on a ring, with a red-and-white fishing bobber that had the paint chipped off one side.
Lauren stopped moving. The paper slid off her lap onto the floor. She picked up the key ring with two fingers, very slowly, and the bobber swung back and forth.
“Where did you get this?” she whispered. “That was my mom’s.”
“I know it was.”
“She had this in her purse. She had it in her purse at the hospital.” She looked up at me, and her face had gone white. “Where did you get it?”
“Read the paper, honey.”
She unfolded the deed. I watched her eyes go down the page and then back up to the top to start again. Her lips were moving. When she got to the legal description, the lot number on Loon Lake, she made a sound as if someone had knocked the wind out of her.
“What is it?” Frank said. He’d come to stand behind her chair. “Lauren, what is it?”
She handed it up to him without a word. He patted his shirt pocket for his glasses and read it standing there with the tree lights blinking on his face. Then he lowered the page and looked at me, and I couldn’t tell at all what he was thinking.
“Carol,” he said. “What did you do?”
“I bought it,” I said. “Two years ago in October. From Gary. That paper signs it over to Lauren. It’s been hers since the day I signed it, as far as I’m concerned. It only needs to be recorded.”
“With what?” Frank said. “You bought it with what?”
“The money from my house. And Ray’s insurance.”
Nobody in that living room made a sound. Josephine had her hand at her throat. Peggy was staring at me with her mouth open, and for once in her life she had nothing to say.
Lauren was still holding the keys. She turned the bobber over in her fingers. On the white half, in faded marker, were the initials D.M., which I had noticed the first day and which I assume Diane put there when she was a girl.
“You’re the woman,” Lauren said slowly. “The cash buyer. That was you.”
“That was me.”
“I went up there. I stood in the yard.” Her voice was climbing. “I sat on those steps and cried, and it was yours? You had it the whole time?”
“It was never mine. I was keeping it for you.”
“For two years?” She stood up, and the box fell off her lap. “You let me think it was gone for two years! You sat at this table and listened to me talk about it and you didn’t say one word!”
She wasn’t wrong, and I had known for a long time that she’d say exactly that.
“I was going to give it to you that first Christmas,” I said. “It was wrapped. It was in the closet. And then you told me I couldn’t buy my way into being your mother.”
Lauren flinched.
“You were right about that,” I said. “I can’t, and I wasn’t trying to. But I knew if I handed you a house the next morning, that’s what you’d think it was. So I waited for a better time. Then last year you didn’t come.” I looked at the snowman box on the floor by my chair. “I finally figured out there wasn’t going to be a better time.”
She opened her mouth and closed it. Her eyes went to the diapers and the brochure, and I saw it land on her, what she had just done and what she was holding in her hand. Her whole face crumpled.
“I didn’t want you to lose it,” I said. “That’s all it ever was. I heard you ask your dad that night, and I had the money sitting in a bank doing nothing. I never met your mother, and I’m not trying to be her. I didn’t think her steps ought to belong to a dentist from Chicago.”
Lauren put the back of her hand against her mouth. She was crying, the way she must have cried as a little girl, with her shoulders up around her ears.
Josephine spoke up from the wing chair. She’s a tiny woman, and she doesn’t say much anymore, but when she does, the family listens.
“Lauren Marie,” she said. “You pick that box up off the floor and you put it out in the garbage where it belongs. And then you come back in here.”
Lauren didn’t move at first. Then she bent down, picked up the snowman box, and walked out through the kitchen. We heard the back door open and the lid of the trash can bang.
She didn’t come back in. Through the window over the sink, I could see her standing in the driveway in her sweater with no coat, holding the key ring in her fist, with her breath coming out in clouds.
Frank was still standing by the tree with the deed in his hand.
“Peg, would you get Ma some more coffee,” he said quietly. “Carol, come in the kitchen a minute.”
I followed him. He shut the swinging door and leaned against the counter.
“Two years,” he said.
“I know.”
“You drove up there. All those times you said you were at Barb’s.”
“I stopped at Barb’s every time. For about twenty minutes.”
He didn’t smile. “You should have told me. I’m your husband. I’d have said no, and you’d have done it anyway, and I’d have been mad for a month. But I’d have known.” He looked down at the paper. “I couldn’t do it for her. You understand that? I sat at that table and told my daughter I couldn’t help her, and my wife had already…” He stopped.
“That’s why I didn’t tell you,” I said. “I didn’t want you to feel like that.”
“Well, I feel like that now.” He folded the deed along its creases. Then he put his arm around me and pulled me against his chest so hard that my glasses went crooked, and he held on. “I’m still mad,” he said into my hair.
“I know you are.”
He went out to the driveway after that, with her coat over his arm. I stayed in the kitchen and watched through the window, because I couldn’t help it. I couldn’t hear them. I saw him put the coat around her shoulders, and I saw her talking fast and pointing back at the house. Then he said something that went on for a while, and she turned and stared at him.
I found out later what it was. He’d told her about the prenup. He told her that the house had been hers on paper since before the wedding, that I was the one who’d insisted on it, and that the folder she’d seen in October said the same thing. He told her I’d paid for Alaska because he hadn’t had a vacation in six years and I thought he needed one. He said he should have told her all of it a long time ago and that keeping quiet had been his fault.
They were out there twenty minutes. The sticky buns went cold.
When Lauren came back in, her nose was red and her eyes were swollen nearly shut. Everyone in the living room suddenly found something to look at. She walked straight over to my chair. I thought she might hug me, and I braced for it, but she didn’t. She stood in front of me twisting the bobber.
“I’m sorry about the present,” she said. Her voice was hoarse. “It was a rotten thing to do. I knew it was rotten when I bought it.”
“All right,” I said.
“I don’t know what to say about the other thing. I don’t know how to say thank you for that. It’s too big.” She swallowed. “And I’m still kind of mad at you. About the two years.”
“You can be mad. Your father is too.”
That got about half a laugh out of her, and she wiped her nose on her wrist. Then she sat down on the floor by the tree, close to her grandmother’s chair, and she kept the keys in her lap for the rest of the morning. She didn’t say much else to me that day. When she left, she stopped at the front door and looked back as if she were going to add something, and then she just lifted her hand.
I won’t tell you that everything was mended by New Year’s. She still calls me Carol. Sunday dinners are still about one in four.
In January, she called and asked for Susan Abernathy’s number. She went in by herself. Susan told me afterward, with Lauren’s permission, that Lauren had sat in her office and asked whether there was a way to pay me back, at least the taxes and insurance, and whether she ought to refuse the whole thing. Susan told her that a gift isn’t a loan, and that she was free to turn it down if she liked, but that in thirty-five years of practice she’d never seen anyone go to that much trouble to give something away.
The deed went up to the county to be recorded that same week. It came back in February with a stamp across the top, and Susan mailed it to Lauren’s apartment.
Lauren did insist on taking over the taxes from then on. I let her. She also showed up at our door one evening with an envelope of cash for Arnie’s forty dollars a month, two years’ worth, which I told her was ridiculous. We argued about it on the porch for ten minutes, and it’s the longest conversation the two of us have ever had. I took half.
She asked us to come up the third weekend in May, to help open the place. Frank drove. He hadn’t been to the lake since the September he carried Diane down to the dock, and he didn’t say a word for the last eleven miles. When we turned onto the two-track, he reached over and took my hand and held it on the seat between us.
Lauren’s car was already there. She had every window open and the shutters off, and there was a mattress airing over the porch rail. She came out with a broom in her hand and a bandanna over her hair, and she had cobwebs on her shoulder.
“There’s a mouse nest in the silverware drawer,” she said, by way of hello. “And something died under the porch. Dad, I need you.”
We worked all day. Frank crawled under the porch with a flashlight and a garbage bag. I washed forty years of dishes, every plate in the cupboard, while Lauren swept. Arnie came over around noon with a jar of pickled eggs and stood in the yard with his cap in his hands. When Lauren saw him, she dropped the broom and ran down the steps and hugged him, and that old man cried like a child.
In the afternoon, I found her standing in front of the pantry door with her finger on the pencil marks. She was touching her mother’s name, about four feet off the floor, with a date beside it from the sixties.
“She was short,” Lauren said, not turning around. “I passed her when I was twelve. She pretended to be furious about it.”
I didn’t say anything. I dried a plate.
“You didn’t touch the puzzle,” she said.
“It wasn’t mine to finish.”
She nodded. A little later, I saw her sit down at the card table and blow the dust off the covered bridge and fit in a single piece of sky. Then she got up and went back to sweeping.
Frank fell asleep on the porch glider around four with his mouth open. I walked down the steps to the dock. I counted them again out of habit, and I sat at the end with my shoes off and my feet hanging over the water, which was far too cold to put them in. A loon was calling from the other side of the lake.
After a while, the dock boards creaked behind me. Lauren sat down, leaving about two feet between us, and held out a mug. She had another for herself.
“I found Grandma’s percolator,” she said. “It still works. It tastes like a penny.”
I took the mug. She was right about the taste.
“Mom took hers black,” Lauren said, looking out at the water. “I don’t know how you take yours.”
“Cream. And too much sugar.”
“Figures.” She drank some of her own and made a face. “There’s powdered creamer in the cupboard from about 1994. I wouldn’t.”
“I’ll bring some next time,” I said, and then I heard what I’d said and wished I hadn’t assumed.
Lauren didn’t answer right away. She picked at a splinter on the edge of the dock.
“Fourth of July,” she said. “Arnie does fireworks off his raft. They’re terrible. Bring the cream.”
THE END..!